Electric blanket

How often should you replace a pillow? Here is how to tell it’s worn out

25 May, 2024
Last updated on
Johnno van den Brink

Your pillow stays under your head for about seven to eight hours every night. Do you remember when you bought it? Many people don’t. You often read that you should replace a pillow every two to three years, sometimes accompanied by a terrifying figure about bacteria. But how often should you replace a pillow, according to research? There is a surprising answer to that: nobody has researched it. There is no study that supports a fixed timeframe. We do know something about what happens inside a pillow over the years, and there are a few simple ways to see for yourself if it’s worn out.

Where does that two to three-year timeframe come from?

The two to three-year timeframe (sometimes one to two) appears on many websites of manufacturers and shops. A source with actual measurements is usually missing. That doesn’t make the timeframe wrong, but it’s a rule of thumb rather than a research result. Furthermore, a good latex pillow and a cheap polyester pillow don’t last equally long, and someone who sweats a lot or doesn’t use a pillow protector will likely wear out a pillow faster than someone who does.

Pillow in the sunlight

That’s why it’s actually more useful to look at the pillow itself rather than the calendar.

How to know if your pillow is still good?

A few things say more than the purchase date:

How to know if your pillow is still good?
  • The fold test. Fold a fiber or down pillow in half and let go. If it springs back, there’s still life in it. If it stays folded or only halfway returns, the resilience is gone. This doesn’t work for latex and foam. With those, you look for permanent dips, cracks, or crumbling foam.
  • The hand test. Place the pillow on your forearm. If it hangs limp on both sides, it’s providing very little support.
  • Fluffing. If you have to fluff the pillow every night just to get some height, or if the filling is bunched up or lumpy, the filling is spent.
  • Stains and odor. Yellow stains and a musty smell are caused by sweat and sebum soaking into the pillow. Washing sometimes helps to give it extra life; see how do you get yellow stains out of your pillow?
  • How you wake up. If you wake up with a stiff neck more often than before, your pillow could be one of the causes. It’s not a certainty, as neck complaints upon waking are very common. In an Australian study, about one in five participants woke up with complaints at least once in a single week on their own familiar pillow (Gordon et al., 2010).

A fold or hand test is practical experience, not a measured standard. But it does say something about what matters: whether the pillow still keeps your head at the right height.

What’s inside your pillow after a few years?

Here the research is a bit more concrete, and also less appetizing. A pillow absorbs some sweat, sebum, and skin flakes every night, which dust mites live on. In New Zealand, researchers placed a new synthetic and a new feather pillow together on twelve beds for a year. After a year, both pillows contained mite allergens, and the synthetic pillow had about three times as much as the feather pillow. How much ended up in a pillow depended mainly on how much was already in the mattress (Rains et al., 1999). That difference between synthetic and feathers was mainly due to the ticking, not the filling. In a later lab test, live mites crawled through a regular polyester ticking within a day, but not through the ticking of a feather pillow or a more densely woven synthetic ticking (Siebers et al., 2004).

In a small study, British researchers cultured fungi from ten used pillows that were between one and a half and more than twenty (!) years old. They found between four and sixteen species per pillow, more in synthetic than in feather pillows. The most common was Aspergillus fumigatus, a fungus that can cause symptoms in people with asthma or a weakened immune system (Woodcock et al., 2006).

For most healthy people, that’s no reason to panic. Fungal spores and mites are everywhere in the house. It’s different for people with a dust mite allergy or asthma. For them, a pillow that can be washed at 60 degrees, with a well-fitting cover around it, is worth considering. Not sure if your pillow can go in the wash? Then read can you wash a pillow in the washing machine?

And what about that toilet seat?

You might have read somewhere that after a week, your pillowcase contains more bacteria than a toilet seat, sometimes even seventeen thousand times as many. That figure comes from an in-house swab test by an American mattress company, where volunteers sampled their own bedding. It hasn’t been published in a scientific journal and, as far as we could find, has never been repeated by others. Furthermore, it’s about the pillowcase, not the pillow. That a pillowcase lying on your bed for a week collects bacteria surprises no one. How often you should wash it can be found in how often should you replace your pillowcase?

The same applies to the claim that after a few years, a third or a tenth of a pillow consists of skin flakes, mites, and their droppings. These figures have been circulating for years and certainly sound plausible, but we haven’t found a study that has actually weighed it yet.

What helps a pillow last longer?

A pillow protector under the pillowcase catches most sweat and sebum and is easier to wash than a pillow. Regularly airing the pillow itself helps to get rid of moisture. And some pillows can go in the washer and dryer, which often makes the filling a bit fluffier again: see can a pillow go in the dryer?

Still, a pillow remains a consumable item. Fibers break, foam loses resilience, down clumps together. The moment your pillow is worn out doesn’t depend on a date, but on how it performs after intense use.

Replace on time, but when is that?

So perhaps the better question isn’t how old your pillow is, but whether it still does what you bought it for. Does it still keep your head at the same height as when it was new? Does it still spring back? And how do you wake up? Anyone who asks those questions occasionally doesn’t need a calendar. And if you are ready for a new pillow anyway, you’ll find help choosing in how do I choose the perfect pillow?

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does a pillow last?

There is no research on that. Manufacturers and shops usually mention two to three years, but that depends heavily on the filling, the quality, and how you maintain the pillow. The fold test and the hand test say more than the purchase date.

How do you do the fold test?

Why does my pillow turn yellow?

Should I replace my pillow more often if I have allergies?

Sources

  1. Gordon, S.J., Grimmer-Somers, K.A. and Trott, P.H. (2010). Pillow use: the behavior of cervical stiffness, headache and scapular/arm pain. Journal of Pain Research, 3, 137-145. doi.org/10.2147/JPR.S10880
  2. Rains, N., Siebers, R., Crane, J. and Fitzharris, P. (1999). House dust mite allergen (Der p 1) accumulation on new synthetic and feather pillows. Clinical & Experimental Allergy, 29(2), 182-185. doi.org/10.1046/j.1365-2222.1999.00470.x
  3. Woodcock, A.A., Steel, N., Moore, C.B., Howard, S.J., Custovic, A. and Denning, D.W. (2006). Fungal contamination of bedding. Allergy, 61(1), 140-142. doi.org/10.1111/j.1398-9995.2005.00941.x
  4. Siebers, R., Nam, H.S. and Crane, J. (2004). Permeability of synthetic and feather pillows to live house dust mites and house dust. Clinical & Experimental Allergy, 34(6), 888-890. doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2222.2004.01972.x
  5. Amerisleep (n.d.). Bacteria in your bed (in-house swab test by a mattress company, not peer-reviewed). amerisleep.com/blog/bacteria-in-your-bed/